Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Just Some Thoughts

I've mentioned how much I loved the movie Juno. What I haven't said is that I won't allow my daughter to watch it and that I'm a little unsure I approve of any of the Young Women at church seeing it either. If I were to make this point at church, some well-meaning person would likely tell me that if I don't want my children watching something, I shouldn't watch it either. Obviously, I disagree with that. I loved the movie because I am old enough to know that teen aged pregnancy doesn't really end in 'happily ever after.' I can appreciate the story and separate the dreamy ending from the reality of the situation. As the older sister of a one-time teen mom, I think I definitely have some perspective. BUT, I also love a good story. The same is true for most of my favorite shows. In real life, Starbuck and Apollo are a dysfunctional mess with no rooting power whatsoever, but I love to watch them make out on BSG. Do I really think there's anything good or beneficial from a couple of people meeting up once a year to cheat on their spouses? Absolutely not. But Same Time, Next Year is one of my all-time favorite movies. And while I seem to have outgrown them lately, All My Children, Days of Our Lives, and As the World Turns; used to brighten my afternoons every week.

So why is it OK for me and not my impressionable daughter to watch such things? Because I get it and she doesn't. I get that these things are just my preferred form of escapism, my distraction from the day-t0-day drudgery of raising four kids, cleaning house, and working part-time. I understand that behaving myself in real-life the way characters on TV or in a movie would, at the very least, make me look a fool; and at worst, come with permanent negative consequences. But my daughter? The younger youth at church? It's hard to say. I'm proud to write that I've watched very few episodes of Jerry Springer, but I've seen enough to know that this next generation doesn't seem to operate under that same filter of reality. They get an impulse and they act on it with no thought whatsoever for what happens next, and I find that more than a little scary. They see something on a movie and they try it at home. I don't like it, but I see it. As a mom, I hope I do a good job of teaching my children what's real and what's fiction, but until I do; I have a responsibility to make sure they are introduced to the world on a need-to-know basis and there are some things they just don't need to know yet. I, on the other hand, have learned more than my fair share, and I think that justifies the occasional escape from reality as long as I understand that's all that it is. And believe me, I do.

5 comments:

Pixie

Juno is a favorite at our house too (no kids to worry about though). I totally agree with what you say about not being for younger folks either. I tried using that argument on my own mother when I was a teen and I now see the difference. :)

I grew up on AtWT. I haven't watched it in years, I miss it.

Anonymous

You really think the ending was dreamy? The scene that sticks with me is how she cried afterward. I remember being so glad that scene was in there because up until then, yeah, I thought it was played as a bit too "easy" for her. Kind of like the abortion in Fast Times was too "easy" for Jennifer Jason Leigh (my only quibble with that movie, but it's a big 'un). I also had some trouble accepting Juno's dialogue as realistic, but that's really only a small, wow what is it with this word and me today, quibble. Essentially, though, to me, almost-perfect movie. I saw two movies in the theater last year, and I feel so lucky that this was one of them. ("Once" was the second -- I feel equally as lucky. Do check it out if you haven't -- I think you'd love it!)

sandra

Anonymous

I should add ... in the context of letting the kiddos watch it, yeah, I agree with you.

sandra

Swistle

I never understand the "double standard" complaint. OF COURSE there is a double standard. This is exactly where a double standard BELONGS. We don't allow 7-year-olds to drink vodka, but at 34 years old I may make my own decision if I want to drink it or not. The 9-year-old must go to bed at the same time each night; maybe I should too, but I don't have to. A child may not watch a racy movie, but I may.

And of course: some movies and books deal with issues that are too mature for younger children and teenagers. That doesn't mean they're too mature for adults.

Leeann

Juno. Oh, how I loved that movie.

  © Blogger template 'BrickedWall' by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Jump to TOP