Back when I published regularly, I was still a very active member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. That began to fall by the wayside in 2010, by the time the 2015 "Exclusion Policy" leaked and the church leaders doubled down on it in response, our whole family knew it was time to step back and think about what we actually believed. Ten year later, we are still thinking about it.
In the interim, I have attended a couple of funerals and another service when a friend's son was preparing to leave on his mission. (Because, in her words, "If I've gotta go, you've gotta go." And honestly, it was a great day.) Watching the MoTab choir sing at the 2017 inauguration was a gut punch. I was angry at the obvious political endorsement which went against everything I believe about the separation of church and state. But I was also sad, because I could have told each and every singer, each and every church member who backed the new president, that he didn't want any of them, just their money and their vote. That's all he wants from all of us. And while I acknowledge the existence of more nuance than that, I don't see it. All I see is someone who feels entitled to pit us against each other for nothing more than personal gain. And I still believe that America has always had the potential to be better than a bunch of petty playground kids 'owning' each other. While, sadly, there were many incidents that tried to prove me wrong over the weekend, I'm going to focus on the one that hit closest to home, obviously the shooting and arson in Grand Blanc, MI.
While I'm not sure me, my husband, or any of our adult and almost adult children have any interest in returning to church. We cried with the rest of the country-or so we thought-on Sunday as images of the smoldering building in ruins invaded our tv and social media spaces. It is heartbreaking in any circumstance, but the most active we were as a family was when my children were little and because most LDS church buildings look the same, all seven of us could picture exactly how the scenario unfolded and what it could have looked like for us just a few short years ago. It hit all of us very deeply and none of us were quite sure why except that we can all picture it so vividly and all of us still have people we love who are still active members. A quick scroll though Threads and Facebook reassured me that we weren't the only less active and former members who had taken this completely to heart. But what has shocked me is that it seems to be only us along with the active members who are reeling in hurt and shock. The rest of the so-called Christian world, not so much.
Instead of mourning at the levels we all saw for Charlie Kirk, these 'brothers and sisters in Christ are more inclined to return ridiculous arguments over whether church members are Christian or not and therefore whether they are "worthy" of love, attention, and support. And here are all of us who exited stage left years and decades ago finding ourselves in the awkward position of vehement defenders of a faith that we chose to step away from willingly. It would be funny if it weren't so sad. As is always the case, the awkward silence of Christian Nationalists who are very interested in the church's resources, just not quite being able to bridge the gap when it comes to accepting them as equals or fellow Christians. And again, it makes me so sad to watch the church members collectively do everything they can for a seat at the table only to be denied true fellowship, even under the worst of circumstances. Or at least I sure haven't seen any flags at half-staff or anything else remotely resembling the outcry at the death of Mr. Kirk. I have believed since 2016 that all the church was for them was a number of votes and a healthy infusion of cash. And yet, it hurts to be proven right, even when I no longer have a dog in this particular fight.
I am heartbroken for the members in Grand Blanc, but also relieved to feel like not much more than a bystander in all of this, albeit one with a bit more insight than most. I may have my issues with the church and I haven't changed my mind, but now is not the time to air those in detail. Instead, it's time to once again acknowledge my duty to 'mourn with those that mourn' and to honor those who were hurt and even killed simply because they chose to help someone they thought was in trouble. It doesn't reallly matter whether I agree with them about religion or anything else at this particular moment. I am told that the majority of the gunshot victims sustained those injuries racing to try and help the perpetrator when he drove his truck into the building. And picturing that makes me think of one of the most poignant speeches from The West Wing which I will close with in a moment. I know our country is a divided mess. But I refuse to let it divide from the people I love. And I know that all of us, no matter what we believe or don't believe, will one day walk those 'crowded streets' together. But that doesn't mean we should wait until we get there before we remember we have it in us to be better. This isn't anything leaders on any particular side are going to tell us right now. I don't think they want us to know. But it's something I still believe we can figure out for ourselves. I may not recognize the church anymore, but I still believe in the good people I knew there. I may not recognize our nation in this particular moment. But I still believe in its potential for greatness.
